4. Is singed statement given to police under CrPC 161 holds more weight than unsigned statement? Thank you very much. Govind

Situation : Dear Sir, In my 498a case, the father and brother of my Wife, who gave statements to police under CrPC161, have given up as witness in the court, their statements being unnecessary, as stated by APP to Court. Before this, the other PWs (including my wife and her mother) who appeared from my wife's side, they couldn't stand most of the questions posed to them during cross-examination and mostly replied that they don't remember the asked details. My queries are:- 1. Is it permissible in law that persons who are in blood relation and based on whose testimony the final report/challan was submitted in Court leading to institution of the case u/s 498a/406/34 against us, can these family members/persons give up from appearing in Court as witnesses? 2. Can such persons who gave up as witness in Court be compelled by respondents (us) to appear and depose? 3. Is there any law/ruling/case law by SC citing which such persons who gave up as witness in criminal case be made to appear and depose or is there any provision for penalty/fine for such persons for misleading the criminal justice machinery?
Related Topics : Criminal Law
Lawyers answer this question

Advocate Justice Kishan Dutt Kalaskar

Bangalore 
For More Details Contact On +91 7769012300.
A:

Dear Friend,

If public prosecutor failed to examine any Charge Sheeted witness then you may take benefit out of it instead of summoning them (which is permissible under Law) as your witnesses since they may spoil your defense and on the other hand strengthen the case of prosecution side.

Secondly, normally in India examination of blood related relatives is not barred and conviction may be based on the sole testimony of such witnesses.

If you send entire records through courier then i will be in a position to advise you properly.

92 user found this answer helpful

Disclaimer : This answer is based on information given by you hence, It is just opinion of Lawyer. For specific answer you have to give details and facts and choose the Lawyer of your choice.

Lawyers: To answer this question, please Sign In to your account or wait for admin approval.

Most Viewed Lawyers